User's review


Show all reviews for this movie

[ATTENTION: This review reveals content of the movie.]
There is something wrong with this production, and I will return to that later. The praise heaped on it is mostly warranted, except for the performance of Keira Knightly, who poses her way through the film. The Dunkirk beach shot is ingenious and worth the price of admission alone. Not having read about the plot in advance, I was sandbagged by the change of narrative position near the end. There are many movies which tell the story from a number of perspectives, in the Rashomon tradition, or with time shifts like Memento, but the shift in this one seems just too arbitrary. With only the one shift, I almost felt as if they had given the story to a sociopath without warning us that there was one in the room. What personality disorder would you assign to a character who opens mail, gossips about the content, gives false testimony with the result of destroying lives, only to reassemble a published fabrication decades later in a self-exculpatory manner?

6/10eql@ - 38 reviews
26.12.2007 - age: 50+


Note: The review posted on this page is a personal opinion of our reader. We are not responsible for its content.

Did you see ''Atonement''?

Write a movie review and you could WIN free tickets!!! (details about the promotion)

How do you rate this movie?


Please explain. Write your comment here:


Your age:     Male:   Female: (optional)

Your e-mail:

You will receive a confirmation of your comment by e-mail.
We reserve the right to reject your comment at our discretion.


Mobile · iPhone · Home · Top 10 · Trailers · Playing · Upcoming · Theatres · Movies · DVD · Promotions · Change City · USA · Contact Us · Français
Terms and Privacy Policy under which this service is provided to you.
© 1996-2013 CinemaClock Canada Inc.