Just Like Heaven [2005] Critiques sur CinemaMontreal.com

Allons-y chronologiquement: 1re déception: le changement de noms par rapport à l'oeuvre originale 2e déception: Le changement des personnes évoluant autour de la protagoniste. 3e déception: la fin, beaucoup trop Hollywoodienne. Lorsque j'avais lu le livre et avais appris que Spielberg avait acheté les droits, j'étais persuadé que l'intégrité de l'oeuvre serait préservée. Spielberg n'a pas réalisé le film, dommage parce que Waters a raté son coup. Prévisible, ennuyant et simpliste, tout le contraire de l'oeuvre littéraire de Levy. Bon casting toutefois, Reese Witherspoon est excellente et Mark Ruffalo aussi.

Titre	Vote
Maurice Richard [2005]	10/10
Life Is Beautiful [1998]	10/10
Braveheart [1995]	10/10
Band of Brothers [TV]	10/10
Eight Below [2006]	10/10
Lions for Lambs [2007]	9/10
Shrek the Third [2007]	9/10
Remember The Titans [2000]	9/10
Radio [2003]	9/10
The Notebook [2004]	9/10
The Pianist [2002]	9/10
The Professional [1994]	9/10
Platoon [1986]	9/10
Philadelphia [1993]	9/10
Million Dollar Baby [2004]	9/10
National Treasure [2004]	9/10
Mississippi Burning [1988]	9/10
Flags of Our Fathers [2006]	9/10
The Matrix [1999]	9/10
Men Of Honor [2000]	9/10
The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring [2001]	9/10
The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers [2002]	9/10
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King [2003]	9/10
Kingdom of Heaven [2005]	9/10
Joyeux NoÃ«l [2005]	9/10
JFK [1991]	9/10
I Am Sam [2002]	9/10
The Hurricane [2000]	9/10
La Grande sÃ©duction [2003]	9/10
Glory [1989]	9/10
Gettysburg [1993]	9/10
Finding Neverland [2004]	9/10
Forrest Gump [1994]	9/10
Enemy At The Gates [2001]	9/10
Das Boot [1981]	9/10
Downfall [2004]	9/10
Big Fish [2003]	9/10
The 13th Warrior [1999]	9/10
1984 [1956]	9/10
La Ligne brisÃ©e [2008]	8/10
Vantage Point [2008]	8/10
Spider-Man 3 [2007]	8/10
The Good Shepherd [2006]	8/10
Les RiviÃ¨res pourpres [2000]	8/10
The Road To Perdition [2002]	8/10
The Ring [2002]	8/10
Resident Evil [2002]	8/10
The Replacement Killers [1998]	8/10
Rambo: First Blood [1982]	8/10
Rambo: First Blood Part 2 [1985]	8/10
Raiders Of The Lost Ark [1981]	8/10
300 [2007]	8/10
Babel [2006]	8/10
The Quiet American [2002]	8/10
QuÃ©bec-MontrÃ©al [2002]	8/10
Le Placard [2001]	8/10
Pirates of the Caribbean [2003]	8/10
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest [2006]	8/10
The Departed [2006]	8/10
The Others [2001]	8/10
Le Pacte Des Loups [2001]	8/10
The Pelican Brief [1993]	8/10
The Mummy Returns [2001]	8/10
Monsters, Inc. [2001]	8/10
My Big Fat Greek Wedding [2002]	8/10
Mission: Impossible 3 [2006]	8/10
La MystÃ©rieuse Mademoiselle C. [2002]	8/10
Gridiron Gang [2006]	8/10
Miracle [2004]	8/10
Monsieur Batignole [2002]	8/10
The Number 23 [2007]	8/10
The Mighty [1998]	8/10
Mission: Impossible [1996]	8/10
Le MystÃ¨re de la chambre jaune [2003]	8/10
Mrs. Doubtfire [1993]	8/10
The Guardian [2006]	8/10
Invincible [2006]	8/10
MalÃ¨na [2000]	8/10
Madagascar [2005]	8/10
Memento [2001]	8/10
The Mask [1994]	8/10
Malcolm X [1992]	8/10
The Last Samurai [2003]	8/10
Lord of War [2005]	8/10
The Last Castle [2001]	8/10
The Lion King [1994]	8/10
Legends Of The Fall [1994]	8/10
Kill Bill: Volume 1 [2003]	8/10
Kill Bill: Volume 2 [2004]	8/10
K-19: The Widowmaker [2002]	8/10
The Karate Kid [1984]	8/10
Just Like Heaven [2005]	8/10
John Q [2002]	8/10
Jumanji [1995]	8/10
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire [2005]	8/10
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone [2001]	8/10
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets [2002]	8/10
Ice Age [2002]	8/10
Hitch [2005]	8/10
The Illusionist [2006]	8/10
Hochelaga [2000]	8/10
Highlander [1986]	8/10
The Hunt for Red October [1990]	8/10
Gladiator [2000]	8/10
Night at the Museum [2006]	8/10
Gaz Bar Blues [2003]	8/10
The Goonies [1985]	8/10
Ghost Dog: Way Of The Samurai [2000]	8/10
La Guerre des Tuques [1984]	8/10
Finding Nemo [2003]	8/10
Fun with Dick and Jane [2005]	8/10
La Forteresse Suspendue [2001]	8/10
Full Metal Jacket [1987]	8/10
Footloose [1984]	8/10
Fahrenheit 9/11 [2004]	8/10
The Experiment [2002]	8/10
Equilibrium [2002]	8/10
Effroyables jardins [2003]	8/10
The English Patient [1996]	8/10
Rocky Balboa [2006]	8/10
The Da Vinci Code [2006]	8/10
The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe [2005]	8/10
Crash [2005]	8/10
The Count Of Monte Cristo [2002]	8/10
Billy Elliot [2000]	8/10
L'Auberge espagnole [2003]	8/10
American History X [1998]	8/10
The Adventures Of Baron Munchausen [1988]	8/10
Apollo 13 [1995]	8/10
13 Days [2000]	8/10
Munich [2005]	8/10
The Road to Guantanamo [2006]	8/10
Casino Royale [2006]	8/10
Flyboys [2006]	8/10
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford [2007]	7/10
Perfect Stranger [2007]	7/10
Shooter [2007]	7/10
The Blood Diamond [2006]	7/10
Rising Sun [1993]	7/10
Red Dawn [1984]	7/10
Ready To Rumble [2000]	7/10
Les RiviÃ¨res pourpres 2: les anges de l'apocalypse [2003]	7/10
Resident Evil: Apocalypse [2004]	7/10
The Replacements [2000]	7/10
Red Heat [1988]	7/10
The Recruit [2002]	7/10
Rambo 3 [1988]	7/10
The Prestige [2006]	7/10
Pearl Harbor [2001]	7/10
Planet Of The Apes [2001]	7/10
Open Water [2003]	7/10
The Panic Room [2002]	7/10
Over the Hedge [2006]	7/10
L'OdyssÃ©e d'Alice Tremblay [2002]	7/10
Old School [2003]	7/10
Paycheck [2003]	7/10
The Omen [2006]	7/10
A Night At The Roxbury [1998]	7/10
Pleasantville [1998]	7/10
The Neverending Story [1984]	7/10
Patriot Games [1992]	7/10
Mission: Impossible 2 [2000]	7/10
The Mummy 1 [1999]	7/10
My Super Ex-Girlfriend [2006]	7/10
Mortal Kombat [1995]	7/10
The Covenant [2006]	7/10
The Matrix Reloaded [2003]	7/10
The Matrix Revolutions [2003]	7/10
Matroni et Moi [1999]	7/10
The Majestic [2001]	7/10
Mambo Italiano [2003]	7/10
Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World [2003]	7/10
A Man Apart [2003]	7/10
The Manchurian Candidate [2004]	7/10
Lara Croft: Tomb Raider [2001]	7/10
The Longest Yard [2005]	7/10
Legally Blonde 2: Red, White and Blonde [2003]	7/10
Legally Blonde 1 [2001]	7/10
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life [2003]	7/10
Crank [2006]	7/10
Laura Cadieux... La Suite [1999]	7/10
La Loi Du Cochon [2001]	7/10
Knockaround Guys [2002]	7/10
King Arthur [2004]	7/10
Josie And The Pussycats [2001]	7/10
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban [2004]	7/10
Ice Age 2: The Meltdown [2006]	7/10
Alien vs. Predator [2004]	7/10
The Bourne Identity [2002]	7/10
Hostel [2006]	7/10
Les Boys 2 [1998]	7/10
Les Boys 1 [1997]	7/10
I Know What You Did Last Summer [1997]	7/10
Home Alone [1990]	7/10
The Girl Next Door [2004]	7/10
Gosford Park [2002]	7/10
The Great Raid [2005]	7/10
The Fast And The Furious 1 [2001]	7/10
Freaky Friday [2003]	7/10
Flightplan [2005]	7/10
Eurotrip [2004]	7/10
Fanfan la tulipe [2002]	7/10
Duo [2006]	7/10
Dance With Me [1998]	7/10
Catch Me If You Can [2002]	7/10
Les Chevaliers du ciel [2005]	7/10
Sweet Home Alabama [2002]	7/10
Brice de Nice [2004]	7/10
Accepted [2006]	7/10
Eragon [2006]	7/10
10 Things I Hate About You [1999]	7/10
The 40 Year-Old Virgin [2005]	7/10
Superman Returns [2006]	7/10
28 Weeks Later... [2007]	6/10
Children of Men [2006]	6/10
Harsh Times [2005]	6/10
Reign of Fire [2002]	6/10
OSS 117: Le Caire nid d'espions [2006]	6/10
The Musketeer [2001]	6/10
Jungle 2 Jungle [1997]	6/10
Les Boys 3 [2001]	6/10
The Bourne Supremacy [2004]	6/10
Les Boys IV [2005]	6/10
Night Watch [2004]	6/10
The Fast and the Furious: Tokyo Drift [2006]	6/10
End Of Days [1999]	6/10
Enemy Of The State [1998]	6/10
Absolute Power [1997]	6/10
The Patriot [2000]	5/10
The One [2001]	5/10
Miami Vice [2006]	5/10
The Mod Squad [1999]	5/10
Land of the Dead [2005]	5/10
Firewall [2006]	5/10
Take the Lead [2006]	5/10
Mortal Kombat 2: Annihilation [1997]	4/10
Pulse [2006]	3/10
No Country for Old Men [2007]	1/10

Ce film ne m'intéressait pas, ma soeur a commencé à l'écouter pendant que j'étais dans le salon... et finalement j'ai immédiatement accroché.. J'ai tout de suite adoré le personnage joué par Reese... Ensuite, j'ai été fasciné par ce qui se passait... C'est une histoire d'amour originale et drôle... Le tout est très bien pensé, et franchement, ça fait passer un très beau moment! Les scènes avec Jon Heder sont particulièrement drôle et intéressantes, ainsi que celles avec Donal Logue... Franchement, j'ai vraiment l'intention de lire le livre, ainsi que sa suite!